bug: inbound knocking over federation doesn't work #2385

Open
opened 2026-10-19 09:12:23 +00:00 by sugary · 2 comments

What is the bug?

rooms with a join_rule set to knock don't seem to allow knocking over federation, any remote servers that send knock requests fail, while local knocks seem to work. knocking on a room hosted on c10y fails, while knocking on a room hosted on synapse and tuwunel work fine.

Steps to reproduce

  1. create a room on c10y with join_rule set to knock
  2. add and publish an address
  3. try to knock on said room on a different server
  4. it fails, not sending any requests

Server name and version

sugary.gay, continuwuity 26.9.1 (b0a5caf)

Additional context

logs from attempting to join from synapse: {"errcode":"M_FORBIDDEN","error":"Signature verification failed: ed25519 signature verification failed: signature error"}, the signature appears to be correct according to the matrix federation tester, i don't have an account on another c10y instance to get logs by joining from c10y, there's nothing in the logs on the homeserver.

### What is the bug? rooms with a join_rule set to knock don't seem to allow knocking over federation, any remote servers that send knock requests fail, while local knocks seem to work. knocking on a room hosted on c10y fails, while knocking on a room hosted on synapse and tuwunel work fine. ### Steps to reproduce 1. create a room on c10y with join_rule set to knock 2. add and publish an address 3. try to knock on said room on a different server 4. it fails, not sending any requests ### Server name and version sugary.gay, continuwuity 26.9.1 (b0a5caf) ### Additional context logs from attempting to join from synapse: `{"errcode":"M_FORBIDDEN","error":"Signature verification failed: ed25519 signature verification failed: signature error"}`, the signature appears to be correct according to the matrix federation tester, i don't have an account on another c10y instance to get logs by joining from c10y, there's nothing in the logs on the homeserver.
Owner

Does federation work between the servers involved other than that? (Are messages received immediately and so on?)

Does federation work between the servers involved other than that? (Are messages received immediately and so on?)
Author

@Jade wrote in #2385 (comment):

Does federation work between the servers involved other than that? (Are messages received immediately and so on?)

yeah, everything works fine, other than the knocks, found something way worse with it though, waiting on confirmation if it's bad enough to disclose publicly or not

@Jade wrote in https://forgejo.ellis.link/continuwuation/continuwuity/issues/2385#issuecomment-37948: > Does federation work between the servers involved other than that? (Are messages received immediately and so on?) yeah, everything works fine, other than the knocks, found something way worse with it though, waiting on confirmation if it's bad enough to disclose publicly or not
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set

Reference
continuwuation/continuwuity#2385
No description provided.